Sanibel Island All Inclusive Resorts Compared

Deciding between all inclusive Sanibel Island resorts or a regular beachfront resort? Sanibel Island is a great spot for a relaxing vacation on the beach but is it worth going all-inclusive to contain costs. 

There are a number of compelling reasons to choose a Sanibel Island family vacation. We go through the best resorts for both families and romance / luxury seekers here.

We will also mention some of the best features of each resort and what they offer guests. We hope this article helps you find a resort that is perfect for your needs!

Sanibel Island provides one of the best family vacations spots in the USA. This tropical island is set on over 400 acres of land and is only 5 miles long. The island has a wide array of activities to keep your family busy, including fishing, kayaking, swimming, boating, biking, golfing and more!

First stop to finding a fantastic Sanibel Island vacation package is the Top 25 Sanibel Island Resort Deals.

If you don't know much about Sanibel, taking a look at the official Sanibel Island tourism website can help. It can help point you toward the area you'd like to stay in. 

Best Sanibel Island Resorts on the Beachfront

The Sanibel Island is a place where you can relax and enjoy the beauty of nature.

Sanibel Island is one of the most popular tourist destinations in Florida. It is located on the Gulf Coast and it is known for its long stretch of soft, sandy beaches. The island has many attractions such as bird watching, shelling, fishing, and boating.

Then you really want to take advantage of these beachfront resorts is you can. 

Tortuga Beach Club Resort

Tortuga Beach Club Resort is a four-star resort on Sanibel Island, Florida. It offers guests a variety of amenities and services.

  • The resort offers the following amenities:
  • Four restaurants on site
  • A spa with yoga classes, massage therapy, and facials
  • A fitness center with personal trainers and a gym with cardio machines
  • Four pools and two hot tubs
  • Wireless internet in all public areas

Located on the beach, this is award-winning resort is our top pick. We should mention right-off that reviews here are nearly perfect. (A very unusual thing to make everybody happy.)

There's a heated pool and whirlpool spa, 4 tennis courts, picnic areas, watersport rentals, volleyball, golf nearby and a supervised recreation programs.

Accommodations are in 2 bedroom town homes with screened balconies. They have fully equipped kitchens.

Reviewers say: great beach access, loved the hammocks, beautifully landscaped, not too large and doesn't seem crowded. And as we mentioned above, reviews are fantastic.

Pros: The Tortuga Beach Club Resort is a luxurious resort with a relaxed atmosphere. The resort has an array of amenities and activities to keep you entertained. The grounds are beautifully landscaped, and the pool is large enough to accommodate everyone. The rooms are spacious and clean, with all the amenities that you would expect from a hotel at this price point.

This resort welcomes all members of your family with open arms, including pets! There are plenty of activities for kids both inside and outside, including nightly movies on the lawn or in the theater room. There is also a children’s play area with toys and games just waiting for your little ones to come play!

Tortuga Beach Club Resort offers many dining options to satisfy any appetite or craving. 

More on Tortuga Beach Club Resort.

History: The Tortuga Beach Club Resort on Sanibel Island Florida is a luxury resort with a rich history and heritage. The resort was founded in the early 1900s by William J. Davis, an entrepreneur from Chicago who saw the potential for a luxury resort on this pristine barrier island. In the 1930s, Davis’ son-in-law, Walter J. Haines, Jr., took over ownership of the property and it became known as “The Haines”.

In 1993, The Haines was purchased by its current owners, George Fertitta III and his wife Janice Fertitta. They renamed it “Tortuga Beach Club” and embarked on a major renovation project that included adding new guest rooms, suites and villas.

Sanibel Moorings Resort - Ideal for Families

Award: Best Sanibel Island Family Resort

Sanibel Moorings Resort is a resort on Sanibel Island, Florida. The resort has an ideal location with its proximity to the Gulf of Mexico and the Sanibel Lighthouse Park. It offers a variety of amenities, activities and services to meet the needs of families.

The resort has a 9-hole golf course that is open to residents and guests. There are also tennis courts, a fitness center and a playground for children. The onsite restaurants serve seafood, continental cuisine as well as American favorites.

The resort also provides some unique amenities such as an outdoor pool with cabanas, boat slips for rent and an abundance of wildlife in the area including dolphins, manatees and sea turtles.

This resort is highly rated by past guests - especially families. It's on the north (quiet) end of the island by the historic lighthouse. If you enjoy gardens and plants, there are botanical gardens here (including hibiscus and a butterfly garden).

Sanibel Moorings

Boats are welcome here and it's a great spot for fishing - even right off the dock. There are also pools, a kiddie pool, tennis and of course a great beach. 

Accomodations are in 1-3 bedroom condos with kitchens. Past guests love the clean condos and also the location of this resort.

More information on Sanibel Moorings resort.

Video by the resort:

Sanibel Siesta on the Beach

Sanibel Siesta is a beachfront resort with a heated pool, tennis, and shuffleboard. You'll stay in condos upgraded kitchens, DVD players and free wifi. 

This resort gets fantastic reviews from past guests. People have spotted dolphins from the shore, they love the cleanliness and sound of the ocean and say that the condos have everything you need.

More information on Sanibel Siesta Resort.

Lighthouse Sanibel Island Resort & Club

The Lighthouse Sanibel Island Resort & Club is located in the heart of Sanibel Island, Florida. It is a premier resort destination for couples and families looking for a serene, natural environment with access to the Gulf of Mexico.

The resort offers a variety of amenities, including spa services, fitness center and golf course. The resort also has an award-winning restaurant that features fresh seafood from local waters.

Located on the West Coast of the island, this is a condominium resort hotel.

Lighthouse Sanibel Island Resort & ClubLighthouse Sanibel Island Resort & Club

There are tennis courts, nature trails, wildlife preserves, pool, basketball, shuffleboard, horseshoes, and a hot tub.

Reviewers say: great place to stay with your family, huge, clean, well maintained, a bit dated, units are conveniently located, knowledgeable staff, kitchen is fully equipped. 

Reviews can be mixed so check here for the latest: Lighthouse Resort & Club

Casa Ybel Sanibel Island Resort

This 3 star resort is perfect for those who love nature. The resort owners are very knowledgeable about the Sanibel eco-system.

There's a beach full of exotic shells, pool, kiddie pool, nature sanctuary, spa treatments, boating, fishing, tennis courts and golf privileges.

The resort has an award-winning restaurant, The Pointe Restaurant, which serves fresh seafood dishes and gourmet entrees. There are also two bars on site that offer an extensive selection of wines, spirits and cocktails.

There are 114 one and two-bedroom suites with views of the Gulf of Mexico. They have private balconies or terraces.

Pros: The resort has an award-winning restaurant, The Pointe Restaurant, which serves fresh seafood dishes and gourmet entrées. There are also two bars on site that offer an extensive selection of wines, spirits and cocktails.

The resort offers a variety of activities including golf, tennis, beach access, fishing, biking and sailing. There are also many restaurants on the property that offer local cuisine such as seafood and steaks.

Cons: Only 3 star is an issue if you are looking to go upscale.

Reviewers say: grounds are beautiful and well-kept, staff are friendly and attentive, enjoyed the privacy of the beach, great shelling, some say overpriced, great views.

More on Casa Ybel Sanibel Island Resort.

Sanibel Island All Inclusive Resorts

Sanibel Island would have been the perfect place to stay for all-inclusive vacations, but there are few. There are many resorts in Sanibel Island that offer all-inclusive vacations with a variety of amenities and activities for every age group.

Sanibel Island is the perfect place to explore the Florida Gulf Coast. It offers a variety of attractions, such as shelling, bird watching, fishing, or just relaxing on the beach.

Sanibel Island has two all-inclusive resorts registered:

Expedia has a review of the All Inclusive Resorts on Sanabel Island. 

South Seas Island Resort

Award: Best Family Friendly All Inclusive Resort on Sanibel Island

The South Seas Island Resort is a resort hotel on Sanibel Island, Florida. It is located on the Gulf of Mexico and features a beachfront location. The resort has been awarded with the TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence for the past 5 consecutive years. This review of South Seas Island Resort will cover its facilities, amenities, location, and pricing.

Facilities: The resort has a range of facilities including an outdoor pool with a poolside bar, volleyball court, fitness center, and spa services.

Amenities: The amenities at this resort include 2 restaurants (one with an ocean view), room service (available 24 hours), free wifi access in all public areas (including guest rooms) and free parking for all guests. Location: This resort is located on the beachfront of Sanibel Island.

Pricing: The resort has a variety of pricing options. Bookings for less than 3 nights can be made for approximately $150 per night and reservations for longer stays are available at discounted rates.Facilities: The facilities at this resort include a fitness center, outdoor pool with an ocean view, spa

Pros: Located on a private beach in the Greater Captiva area, the South Seas Island Resort is famous for its unspoiled beaches, tropical gardens and luxurious accommodations.

The South Seas Island Resort on Sanibel Island offers a wide variety of amenities and services for guests to enjoy. Visitors can enjoy shopping at the village shops or spend time at the beach or poolside lounging with a book from our library. Dining options include casual fare like pizza served poolside at sunset or more formal options like fine dining in our Beach House restaurant where guests can enjoy their meal overlooking the Gulf of Mexico.

Cons: There are better rated beach resorts

See all-inclusive packages deals on Expedia

Song Of The Sea - A Place for Romance

Award: Best Sanibel Island Honeymoon All Inclusive

The Song of the Sea is a luxury resort on Sanibel Island in Florida listed as all-inclusive by TripAdvisor because of the package deals they offer. The resort has just over 200 rooms that are all facing the Gulf of Mexico. They also have two pools, a spa, and beach access. This 3 star resort-hotel is intimate - only 30 rooms - and right on the beach. Couples especially rate this spot highly.

Song of the Sea is famous for its "island-style" cuisine and its golf course. The resort's restaurant, Lighthouse Grill, has been ranked among the top restaurants in Florida by several publications.

There's a pool, continental breakfast, complimentary bicycles, one bar and one restaurant.

The guestrooms and suites have are decorated in creams, mahogany and wicker. They have private screened balconies.

Pros: The Song of the Sea resort is a beautiful place to stay. The staff are very friendly and helpful. The resort is on the beach, so you can enjoy the view of the ocean from your room or just walk down to the shore in a few minutes.

Cons: Small resort

Reviewers say: peaceful and quaint, great staff, bottle of wine in our room on arrival, nice rooms. This resort gets good reviews and has a lot of repeat visitors.

More on the Song Of The Sea.

Sanibel Harbour Marriott Resort & Spa

Sanibel Harbour Marriott Resort & Spa, Florida

This is one of our favourite resorts chosen for it's great spa and beautiful location.

This 5 star resort is not on Sanibel Island but right on the gulf coast in Fort Myers.

Click here to see a full description on the resort.

Conclusion: You might like these Florida Resorts

All Inclusive resorts are a great option for vacationers who enjoy spending more time on the beach. The all-inclusive resort is able to provide their guests with free-flowing alcohol and amenities like pools, water parks, and spas. However, there are many different kinds of all-inclusive resorts on Sanibel Island, which can make it difficult to decide which one is the best for you and the packages available are not as comprensive as you might expect.